Complete comparison of Faire vs traditional distributors. Learn when to use each approach, cost differences, and whether brands can use both.
As Faire has grown, many brands wonder: does Faire replace wholesale distributors? The answer isn't simple,both approaches have distinct advantages, and many successful brands use both. This comprehensive comparison helps you understand when to use Faire vs distributors, cost differences, and how to build a hybrid strategy.
Understanding the differences between Faire and traditional distributors helps you make informed decisions about your wholesale strategy, optimize costs, and maximize market reach.
Traditional wholesale distributors act as intermediaries between brands and retailers:
Distributors typically earn through:
Brands sell to distributors at wholesale prices. Distributors mark up products (20-40%) and sell to retailers. Distributors handle all retailer relationships, sales, and logistics.
Faire is a digital B2B marketplace that connects brands directly with retailers:
Faire earns through:
Brands list products on Faire. Retailers discover and order directly from brands. Faire handles payment processing and terms, but brands ship directly to retailers. No inventory holding or sales reps required.
Here are the fundamental differences between Faire and distributors:
| Aspect | Faire | Distributors |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Digital marketplace, direct to retailer | Intermediary, holds inventory |
| Cost Structure | 15% commission (or 0% Direct) | 20-40% margin |
| Upfront Costs | None | High (shows, reps, samples) |
| Geographic Reach | Global, instant | Limited to network |
| Retailer Access | Thousands, online 24/7 | Limited, relationship-based |
| Relationship Management | Self-service, automated | Personal, high-touch |
| Speed to Market | Fast (days to weeks) | Slower (months) |
| Inventory | Brand holds | Distributor holds |
Understanding cost differences helps you make informed decisions:
Example: $10,000 order = $1,500 commission + $10 new customer fee + $200 processing = $1,710 total fees (17.1%). With Faire Direct: $200 processing only (2%).
Example: $10,000 order = $2,000-$4,000 distributor margin (20-40%) + ongoing rep commissions + upfront show costs. Total cost often 25-50%+ when including upfront investments.
Faire: Lower upfront costs, 15% ongoing commission (or 0% Direct), faster ROI
Distributors: Higher upfront costs, 20-40% ongoing margin, slower ROI but potentially deeper relationships
Faire Direct (0% commission) can be significantly cheaper than distributors, especially for brands bringing their own customers.
Faire is ideal when:
Faire provides instant access to thousands of retailers globally. No need to find distributors, attend trade shows, or hire sales reps.
Faire excels at reaching small retailers who may not meet distributor minimums or attend trade shows. Low MOQs make your products accessible.
Faire requires no upfront investment in trade shows, sales reps, or samples. You only pay when you make sales.
If you're comfortable with online sales and automated systems, Faire's digital platform fits your workflow.
Faire offers transparent, published pricing. No negotiation or relationship-dependent pricing.
Distributors are better when:
Distributors have existing relationships with retailers in specific markets. They can provide immediate access to established accounts.
Distributors provide deep knowledge of local markets, consumer preferences, and regional logistics. Valuable for international expansion.
If your products require personalized service, custom configurations, or complex ordering, distributors provide the hands-on support.
Distributors hold inventory, reducing your warehousing needs and providing faster fulfillment to retailers in their region.
For products requiring specialized handling, local warehousing, or complex distribution, distributors handle logistics expertise.
Yes. Many successful brands use both strategies:
Using both approaches allows you to:
To avoid conflicts:
Faire doesn't necessarily replace distributors, but it provides an alternative channel. Faire is better for: reaching small retailers, rapid geographic expansion, reducing upfront costs, and transparent pricing. Distributors are better for: established relationships, local market expertise, personalized service, and handling complex logistics. Many brands use both: Faire for broad reach and distributors for specific markets or relationships.
The best choice depends on your goals. Faire is better if you want: lower upfront costs (no show fees, rep commissions), rapid expansion, access to small retailers, transparent pricing, and digital-first approach. Distributors are better if you need: established local relationships, personalized account management, complex logistics support, regional market expertise, and high-touch service. Many successful brands use both strategies.
Faire costs: 15% commission (or 0% for Faire Direct), $10 new customer fee (NA) or 10% (international), payment processing fees (1.9-3.5%), no upfront costs. Distributor costs: 20-40% margin/commission, trade show fees ($5K-$50K+), sales rep commissions (10-20%), upfront investment in samples and marketing materials. Faire typically has lower upfront costs but similar ongoing costs. Faire Direct (0% commission) can be significantly cheaper than distributors.
Yes, many brands successfully use both Faire and distributors. Use Faire for: broad market reach, small retailers, rapid expansion, and digital-first customers. Use distributors for: specific geographic markets, established relationships, complex logistics, and high-touch accounts. Coordinate to avoid conflicts: set clear territories, use Faire Direct for existing relationships, and ensure consistent pricing and branding.
Faire is typically faster for: getting started (no trade shows or rep hiring), reaching retailers (immediate online access), order processing (automated systems), and geographic expansion (global reach instantly). Distributors can be faster for: established relationships (immediate access to existing network), local market penetration (existing relationships), and complex custom orders (personalized service). Overall, Faire offers faster initial setup and broader reach.
Faire vs sales reps: Faire provides automated discovery and ordering (24/7), lower upfront costs (no rep salaries/commissions), broader reach (thousands of retailers), transparent pricing, and self-service ordering. Sales reps provide personalized relationships, high-touch service, custom negotiations, local market expertise, and proactive account management. Faire is better for scale and efficiency; reps are better for relationship-driven sales. Many brands use Faire for broad reach and reps for key accounts.
Sign up for free to get insights